Difference Between Guidance Counselling And Psychotherapy Pdf


By Harry H.
In and pdf
17.05.2021 at 02:10
4 min read
difference between guidance counselling and psychotherapy pdf

File Name: difference between guidance counselling and psychotherapy .zip
Size: 2435Kb
Published: 17.05.2021

While in guidance the focus is made on listening to the problem, on which ready-made solution is given by the expert. Psychology is a discipline that studies human behaviour and mind. Two important concepts of psychology, which people do not easily discern are guidance and counseling because both seek to find out the solutions for problems and works for human development.

Visiting a Counselor vs. Psychotherapist

The title shows two extreme positions: Abel was killed by his brother Cain out of jealousy, Pollux, when Castor was killed, asked Zeus to let him share his own immortality with his twin brother to keep them together, and they were transformed into the constellation of Gemini. So, how is the relationship between counselling and psychotherapy? Do they want to have each other out of their way? American addicts, by contrast, often get little more than counselling.

Different countries, different styles — or just different words? But if we use two different words for something, we usually think we talk about two different things. In the Compact Oxford English Dictionary we can read:. To counsel: give advice to give professional help to someone with personal or psychological problems recommend a course of action p. Psychotherapy: the treatment of mental disorder by psychological and not medical means p.

Language thus makes us believe that there are differences between counselling and psychotherapy. For example, we could say that any disorder so most or all the diseases we can find in the ICD needs a therapy. Therefore, counselling is only for healthy people. It happens often that the specialists use the words describing their topic in a way differing from common-sense. Telling people what to do is therefore usually eschewed as a short-term and often counterproductive remedy. So Palmer recommends to ask anyone who uses the terms counselling and psychotherapy exactly how they are using it, and with what justification.

I happily follow this recommendation because I would like to understand what I am talking about…. The overall aim is to provide clients with opportunities to work in self-defined ways, towards living in more satisfying and resourceful ways as individuals and as members of the broader society. So far about counselling. It secures changes targeted to therapeutical goals by empirically verified treatments and methods on the background of theories of diseases and treatment. It bases upon ethical principals.

The quality assurance is carried out by acknowledged rules. Psychotherapy is about radical, far-reaching personality change which is likely to be much more robust than the symptomatic and temporary changes effected by counselling.

But I might be wrong because mostly every one of the schools theoretical orientations, approaches, brand names of psychotherapy and counselling has an own point of view. This makes our topic really complicated. What is this? And coaching? The main difference between the two of them might be the reason for or the topic of this cooperation.

We can find a trend in the scientific literature and on the homepages of several associations: counselling focuses on one or a few specific problems while psychotherapy treats a disease and the personality.

Nestmann offers a helpful symbol to differentiate counselling and psychotherapy: counselling deals more with foreign affairs while psychotherapy deals more with internal affairs.

But what has to be done if a person with a disorder comes to see a psychotherapist with one specific problem? Is the therapist obliged to treat the whole personality?

Mentioning Freud brings us back in to the past. Both of these ways [the Christian and the Adlerian way], which derive their power from being based on analysis, have their place in psychotherapy.

We who are analysts set before us as our aim the most complete and profoundest possible analysis of whoever may be our patient. We do not seek to bring him relief by receiving him into the catholic, protestant or socialist community. We seek rather to enrich him from his own internal sources, by putting at the disposal of his ego those energies which, owing to repression, are inaccessible confined in his unconscious, as well as those which his ego is obliged to squander in the fruitless taste of maintaining these repressions.

If we read this quotation properly we see that Freud does not oppose throwing the light upon a single corner of the mental life but the ideological direction Freud sees in religious or socialist forms of counselling, as we would say today. Another interesting point is his mentioning of enriching the internal sources. It is at least inside the school of Adlerian psychology undisputed that is played an important role in the development of counselling.

Adler and others started in the s in Vienna with counselling teachers and parents because they were convinced that educating and guiding children is the way to avoid future problems and mental diseases. Due to political changes in the s they had to close their counselling centres.

In it, he suggested that the client, by establishing a relationship with an understanding, accepting therapist, can resolve difficulties and gain the insight necessary to restructure his or her life. His type of counselling became known as the Humanistic approach.

This is mostly practiced by counsellors today. Taking a look at the members list of the Swiss Association for Counselling proves this.

After World War II psychosocial counselling became more and more widespread in its fields of activity like working with addicts, victims of violence and abuse, people mourning, families, children, couples, elderly people and so on.

The focus was put on the challenging situation of these people. Models of how to differentiate counselling from psychotherapy followed from the development of a more and more specific identity of counselling.

In the German-speaking countries the following models are discussed: congruence model: there is no difference between counselling and psychotherapy.

The terms are used as synonyms. Difference model : the interventions and offerings can be differentiated clearly. Counselling and psychotherapy have the same concepts of personality, disorder and change. Counselling is for easier problems, not so far-reaching and can be practiced by less educated persons.

Integration model: One is a part of the other one: Either counselling is a part of psychotherapy i. Overlap model: Counselling and psychotherapy are theoretically and empirically different areas of science and practical task with own traditions, methods and approaches but with overlaps in these fields. Probably every country has its own laws to regulate counselling and psychotherapy.

The main duty of laws is the protection of people. How can the counsellors, psychotherapists and their clients or patients be protected and from what?

In Switzerland for example, you need a master degree in psychology to call yourself psychologist. This information is very new and not yet confirmed by the lawmaker. This means the highest non-academical educational level in this professional field. Professional associations are very important for the development of new laws. This gives the profession or at least the members of the association a good reputation and it further offers the lawmaker a blueprint of possible laws.

Individual members of the Swiss Association for Counselling are qualified counsellors who have obtained their qualification at a collective member institution. They have completed a certified counselling training course at least lessons in theory, self-experience and supervision , do continuous further training, supervision and the observation of professional ethical principles and have great life experience. The Joint Russian Association for Psychological Counselling chooses a different approach by defining core competencies for counsellors in the Russian Federation.

Counsellors will show their ability to:. And finally, to become a psychotherapist in Switzerland law requires a master degree in psychology exceptions possible , hours of courses, hours of self-experience, hours of supervision, 2 years of practical experience. Here again we have the approach by defining the amount of needed lessons visited with all its advantages and disadvantages. We now know a little about possible requirements for a counsellor set by an association.

Let us now have a short look at how to become and stay a counsellor or psychotherapist. This served as the starting-point for a discussion, which was eagerly embarked upon, as to what is the training most suitable for an analyst. My own view was and still remains that it is not the training prescribed by the University for future doctors. What is known as medical education appears to me to be an arduous and circuitous way of approaching the profession of analysis.

No doubt it offers an analyst much that is indispensable to him. But it burdens him with too much else of which he can never make use, and there is a danger of its diverting his interest and his whole mode of thought from the understanding of psychical phenomena.

A scheme of training for analysts has still to be created. It must include elements from the mental sciences, from psychology, the history of civilization and sociology, as well as from anatomy, biology and the study of evolution. There is so much to be taught in all this that it is justifiable to omit from the curriculum anything which has no direct bearing on the practice of analysis and only serves indirectly like any other study as a training for the intellect and for the powers of observation.

It is easy to meet this suggestion by objecting that analytic colleges of this kind do not exist and that I am merely setting up an ideal. An ideal, no doubt. But an ideal which can and must be realized. And in our training institutes, in spite of all their youthful insufficiencies, that realization has already begun. We all know that psychology moved towards a fulfilling of this ideal. The way counselling and psychotherapy are taught depends on which model the institute follows.

As a therapist I visited the same courses in theory but had to make some units more. The main difference was in self-experience and supervision. Counsellors needed units in self-experience and 20 units of supervision while psychotherapists needed units in self-experience and units of supervision plus one year of practical experience.

I think only the amount of units is commonly shared by all the different institutes in Switzerland because they are set by the professional associations or the lawmaker.

Theoretically there is another way to become a counsellor or psychotherapist. That one would not focus on the amount of lessons one visits but on the competencies. As a result of this approach the candidates would much more depend on the judgement of the teachers. This is probably the main reason why institutes stopped choosing this way or never chose it.

But the advantage would be that the diploma is based on the skill of the future counsellor or psychotherapist and not on his or her patience. By this, it is setting a high standard which has to be welcomed. I think we all agree that this medical doctor did no proper counselling or psychotherapy. So, becoming a counsellor or a psychotherapist does not only mean that we acquire knowledge and get to know ourselves better. Let us have a look at the core competencies as the Swiss Association for Counselling defines them:.

Basic personality and character competencies: values, attitudes and character traits such as initiative, activity, perseverance, willingness to learn.

What’s the difference between counselling and psychotherapy?

Hi, I am looking for some good indian speakers who can communicate well. You'll be assigned the post based on your communication skills. Some of the posts are Virtual assistant, Writer, Counsellor, story tellers. The only requirement is you should provide atleast 4 to 6 hours daily and atleast hrs before 5 pm IST. Freshers can apply as well. Hi, I need a Psychologist to fill in my school Returning Form. I had a gap last year and my college needs me a Returning-Form if I want to come back to class.


For example, financial planning and spiritual guidance are both types of counseling. Just about anyone may claim to be a counselor if they are in the role of giving.


Difference Between Guidance and Counseling

Counselling and Psychotherapy are often considered to be interchangeable therapies that overlap in a number of ways. Counselling, in specific situations, is offered as part of the psychotherapy process; whereas a counsellor may work with clients in a psychotherapeutic manner. The key difference between the two courses of therapeutic communication treatment lies in the recommended time required to see benefits. Counselling usually refers to a brief treatment that centres around behaviour patterns.

The terms "counselor" and "psychotherapist" are often used interchangeably and have many similarities, but there are some important differences as well. In general, counseling is recommended for specific issues and situations, such as addiction or grief, and takes place over weeks to several months. Psychotherapy, in contrast, tends to explore past issues that might be contributing to present day problems. It often takes place continually or intermittently over a period of years. In actual practice, however, there is a great deal of overlap between the two types of therapies.

Difference between Guidance and Counselling and other discplines

This would mean helping the client make the right career choice, in the case of guidance, or solve a psychological problem, in the case of counselling. Guidance vs Counseling. Difference Guidance: 1. Counseling and guidance both cater towards the development of the individual. Other Differences. It is concerned with the understanding of the individual and the principles, techniques, methods and strategies of counseling and psychotherapy.

Counselling generally refers to short-term consultation while psychotherapy typically refers to longer-term treatment. Counselling normally helps a client process powerful emotions such as grief or anger, deal with immediate causes of stress and anxiety, clarify values and identify options when making important personal or professional decisions, manage conflicts within relationships, develop better interpersonal and communication skills, or intentionally change unproductive thoughts and behaviours. A qualified counsellor must have at least a certificate in counselling, preferably a diploma. The Psychotherapy and Counseling Federation of Australia PACFA requires its members to undergo a minimum of hours of person-to-person training and 50 hours of supervision over a minimum of 3 years. Many mental health professionals are trained and skilled in practicing either counselling or psychotherapy, even integrating them when necessary.


Counselling generally refers to short-term consultation while psychotherapy typically refers to longer-term treatment. Counselling typically deals with present issues that are easily resolved on the conscious level whereas psychotherapy intensively and extensively examines a person's psychological history.


Difference between Guidance and Counselling | Psychology

Need to hire a freelancer for a job?

Guidance and Counselling has been practiced right from time immemorial in an informal manner, today it is well established. Guidance and Counselling works hand in hand with other disciplines to enhance learning and equipping individuals for better life challenges management. However broad as it is, there are existing differences with other disciplines. The comparative analysis between Guidance and Counselling and other disciplines is hereby presented. Guidance is the processes of helping a client understand himself and his environment Sertzer and Stone, While Counselling on the other hand is a person-to-person relationship in which one person helps to resolve an area of conflict that has not been hitherto resolved Thompson and Poppen,

Counselling and Psychotherapy Jobs

Он почувствовал болезненное жжение в боку.

1 Comments

GeremГ­as C.
24.05.2021 at 04:36 - Reply

The title shows two extreme positions: Abel was killed by his brother Cain out of jealousy, Pollux, when Castor was killed, asked Zeus to let him share his own immortality with his twin brother to keep them together, and they were transformed into the constellation of Gemini.

Leave a Reply